skip navigation

Double the fun

By Loren Nelson, 03/02/21, 3:45AM CST


Holy Angels' Hermanson twins, identical in almost every way, fuel victory over Mankato West

Holy Angels' Carter Hermanson beat Mankato West goaltender Caleb Cross for the winning goal in the Stars' 4-2 victory over the Scarlets on Monday. Photo by Loren Nelson,

High school coaches don’t have superpowers, but if they could choose a single, otherworldly ability it might very well be to take take their grittiest, toughest, most tenacious and coachable player and clone him. 

Think of it like that classic old TV jingle for chewing gum: “Double your pleasure, double your fun … double delightment!”

Never mind that delightment isn’t an actual word, and consider the possibilities. Holy Angels coach Pat Griswold could, for example, take 6-foot-2, 190-pound junior forward Noah Hermanson and make an exact copy, name him Carter, and have himself a whale of a forward tandem.

“They are literally the exact same player, and they look exactly the same,” said Griswold, who just happens to a real-life set of Hermanson twins — with no superpowers required … we think. Griswold has coached Noah and Carter since they were freshmen. “Still, to this day, and I am with them every day, I can’t tell them apart.”

Carter Hermanson, who scored the winning goal with 54 seconds left in Monday’s 4-2 triumph over Mankato West at Richfield Ice Arena, let loose with a laugh when he heard about Griswold’s struggles telling the twins apart. The Hermansons do have their tells. Noah, who scored an empty net goal with 25 seconds left to clinch the victory, writes with his left hand. Carter writes with his right hand. Carter shoots left handed. Noah shoots right handed. 

Then there’s the shoes. Jack Bartfield, a slick-stickhandling, smooth-skating sophomore defenseman who fired a long pass that sprung Carter Hermanson on a breakaway for the winning goal, has a foolproof system for determining which twin is which when they are in school.

“Noah wears red shoes and Carter wears Hey Dudes,” said Bartfield, who also scored a first-period power play goal. “At school it’s easy, but here (at the rink) it is kind of hard.”

Griswold said he once tried splitting the twins up, placing them on separate forward lines. The short-lived experiment was a disaster. 

“It’s like, and I mean this in a positive way, they share a brain,” Griswold said. “When they were split up they just weren’t effective without each other. There really is no option of splitting them up.”

As sophomore soccer standouts, the Hermansons led the Stars to an undefeated record en route to the the state Class 1A championship in 2019. The boys’ soccer team, with Carter Hermanson as the leading scorer, went 11-1-1 and won the Section 3A championship in an abbreviated season last fall.

On the ice, as gritty, grinding power forwards, the Hermansons rank first and third in scoring this season for the Stars. Carter has a team-best 26 points, and Noah is the goal-scoring leader with 14. Off the ice, they are stellar students in school and grade-A leaders in the locker room. 

“They helped me through freshman year, and now they are by my side, still helping me,” said Bartfield, who has 25 points. “They took me under their wing and taught me varsity hockey, really.”

The ultra-competitive Hermansons’ tenaciousness was required for Holy Angels (9-4-0) to put away a scrappy Mankato West team that led 2-1 entering the third period. The Scarlets (10-2-2) got outstanding performances from goaltender Caleb Cross (45 saves) and forward Brandon Swenson (1 goal, 1 assist). 

“I have no idea where the kid (Carter Hermanson) came from,” Scarlets coach Curtis Doell said about the winning goal. “All of a sudden I look up and there’s a guy behind our D. We preach to our D, nobody behind, nobody behind, and sure enough there he is.”

Doell said the Stars presented a tougher challenge from what Mankato West normally sees in Big 9 Conference opponents. 

“They would probably beat most (Big 9) teams, I would say, just with their tenacity and speed through the neutral zone. We don’t see a lot of that.”

Watching the Hermansons for three periods, and especially that final minute, no doubt left the Scarlets seeing double.

Holy Angels junior Noah Hermanson, left, takes aim at an empty Mankato West net as Wyant Fowlds defends in the closing seconds of the Stars' 4-2 victory over the Scarlets. Photo by Loren Nelson,

More than 400 interviews

Hundreds of vintage photos

Chapter for every year

Top 10 Charts

Dozens of vignettes

Statistical Leaders

Tourney Time Teasers

  • O What a Relief

  • By David La Vaque 06/09/2020, 5:45pm CDT
  • Hill-Murray's Seamus Regan delighted father, brother by accomplishing what they couldn't
  • Read More
  • Danger Zone

  • By Loren Nelson 03/04/2020, 2:30pm CST
  • Goalies were once allowed to skate to opposite end — and did so at their own peril
  • Read More
  • The Heartbreak Kid

  • By David La Vaque 01/24/2020, 10:30am CST
  • Rob McClanahan and undefeated Mounds View dealt bitter state quarterfinal loss in 1976 by Steve Christoff and Richfield
  • Read More

The Full Nelson

  • Law Aching

  • By Loren Nelson 03/24/2021, 1:00am CDT
  • Andover defenseman Kyle Law takes a beating in his two-way, high-danger role
  • Read More
  • Showtime Raiders

  • By Loren Nelson 03/20/2021, 3:30am CDT
  • Freewheeling Cretin-Derham Hall has top-seed credentials, plenty of doubters
  • Read More
  • The Rights and Wrongs

  • By Loren Nelson 02/15/2021, 6:30pm CST
  • Midseason analysis: A look at the Class 2A teams that have surprised, swooned
  • Read More
  • Follow the Leaders

  • By Loren Nelson 02/08/2021, 3:15pm CST
  • Abundance of leadership could propel St. Thomas Academy great distances
  • Read More
  • The Fantastic Four

  • By Loren Nelson 02/01/2021, 7:00pm CST
  • Hill-Murray extends shutout streak over Edina to unfathomable length
  • Read More